Small Tastings of Torah, Judaism and Spirituality from Rav Binny Freedman – Portion of Shemot
In the year 1263 Raymond de Penyafort of Spain challenged the Jewish people to a debate.
As the church’s representative, he chose a Dominican friar named Pablo Christiani, a Sephardic Jew who had converted to Christianity, to represent them.
The Jewish community came to no less than the Ramban himself, to represent them. The Ramban, Rav Moshe ben Nachman (Nachmanides) was the undisputed great leader of his generation. (His now famous commentaries on the entire Torah and Talmud established him as one of the greatest scholars in Jewish history.) He agreed on condition that he be allowed to respond in the debate. The church was relying on the fact that the Jews would be hesitant to incur the wrath of the church by responding to Christiani’s suppositions, but King James of Aragon, in whose presence the debate took place granted the Ramban free speech.
After the debate the Church published its version of the debate which suggested the Jews had no answers for...
